jemele hill

Ranking New York's "pretty boy" athletes

What's hotter than New York sports? Well, if you believe the gossip magazines and blogs, it's New York's athletes. Yankees third baseman Alex Rodriguez primping in the mirror, new Jets quarterback Mark Sanchez pictured half naked amidst similarly clad women, mentions of Derek Jeter out on the town with . . .

Beauty is in the eye of the beholder, of course, but after some deliberation, we picked out the prettiest of New York's pretty boys and asked some experts - Men's Fitness magazine editor Roy S. Johnson; Deadspin.com creator and New York Magazine writer Will Leitch, and ESPN columnist Jemele Hill - for their comments.